Understanding Transportation Management Systems and Their Benefits for Business

Managing a large-scale logistics company is certainly different from managing last-mile deliveries or courier services. Having previously discussed the Delivery Management System (DMS), this time we will explore the Transportation Management System (TMS).

What is a TMS and how is it different from a Delivery Management System? Find out more in this article.

What is TMS?

A Transportation Management System (TMS) is a system that enables business owners to manage and optimise the shipment of goods. At first glance, a TMS might sound similar to a Delivery Management System (DMS), wouldn't you say?

In fact, although they both focus on shipping goods, their scopes differ. TMS focuses on large-scale deliveries as part of the supply chain, while DMS focuses on customer delivery (last-mile).

A DMS can also be integrated into a TMS, allowing the system to be integrated right down to last-mile delivery. However, many DMSs are also offered as separate systems from a TMS.

Besides being similar to a DMS, you might also think of a TMS as a Fleet Management System. The difference is that an FMS focuses on vehicle management and driver behaviour rather than the dispatch process itself.

Officers refuel the fleet of operational business vehicles managed using a transportation management system.

To be clearer, you can find the differences between TMS, DMS, and FMS in the following table.

Aspect

TMS (Transportation Management System)

DMS (Delivery Management System)

FMS (Fleet Management System)

Main Focus

Manajemen pengiriman barang dalam rantai pasok (supply chain).

Last-mile delivery management.

Vehicle and driver management in fleet operations.

Used by

Logistics companies, distributors, manufacturers and businesses with large shipping volumes.

Expedition services, e-commerce, restaurants, or businesses that frequently send goods directly to customers.

Companies that have many operational vehicles (logistics, ride-hailing, public transportation, etc.).

Key Features

  • Delivery route optimisation

  • Multi-carrier management

  • Tracking shipments (goods)

  • Integration with Warehouse Management System (WMS) & Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP)

  • Tracking real-time kurir/delivery driver.

  • Proof of delivery (Proof of Delivery/POD)

  • Automatic notifications to customers.

  • Last-mile route optimisations

  • Vehicle tracking (GPS, fuel, route).

  • Monitoring driver behaviour (speed, sudden braking, etc.).

  • Vehicle service schedule management.

Coverage

From factory → warehouse → distributor in the supply chain.

From warehouse/store → to end customer.

From a vehicle & driver perspective for fleet efficiency.

Tracking Focus

Shipment/goods, not the vehicle.

Last-mile delivery (courier or driver).

Vehicle & driver, not the goods.

TMS Key Features

Transportation Management Systems typically consist of features that can simplify logistics processes and increase efficiency, such as:

  • Transportation planning: This system makes it easier for you to consider land, sea and air transportation options by providing comparisons.

  • Transportation management: Allows you to manage transportation costs, manage orders, and billing and payments.

  • Delivery monitoring: You can track your delivery in real-time and get notifications if your delivery is delayed or delayed.

  • Document management and compliance: TMS also helps you automate shipping documents and ensure compliance with transportation, tax, and customs regulations.

  • Cost analysis: Can measure the performance and efficiency of costs incurred for delivery and provide data-based reports.

Read Also: Best Fleet Management: How to Maximise Revenue

Benefits of Using TMS for Logistics Businesses

If you currently manage a business that operates in the business and supply chain sectors, using a TMS will be extremely beneficial. Some of the benefits include:

1. Reduce Shipping Costs

Route optimisation is one of TMS's flagship features, allowing you to choose the best route to save fuel. With TMS, you can also get the best advice when choosing the mode of transportation that best suits your needs.

This way, you can determine the best mode of transportation and the budget for each. This allows you to save on shipping costs in the long run without sacrificing delivery quality.

2. Improve Operational Efficiency

By optimizing routes, you can save fuel, which in the long run can also improve operational cost efficiency. However, efficiency in the logistics business is certainly not limited to costs and expenses.

A TMS allows you to simplify long and complex processes. Not only does it save operational costs, it also speeds up and simplifies administrative tasks that are prone to human error.

3. Conduct Real-time Monitoring

Real-time tracking is crucial for monitoring the overall logistics process. It allows you to provide more accurate delivery time estimates to recipients.

Not only that, you can also receive notifications if there are any delivery issues that might cause delays. This eliminates the need to contact and be contacted by the driver directly for regular delivery updates.

4. Simplify Document Management

Every shipment is accompanied by various documents, both related to the shipment itself and to regulatory compliance. Before automation, drivers may have had to carry printed documents that were susceptible to loss or damage.

Using a TMS allows you to digitise shipping documents such as Bills of Lading, Invoices, and Proof of Delivery. This eliminates the need for drivers to carry reams of documents, and makes it easier for you to verify them.

5. Helps data-based decision making

You'll certainly agree that every operational policy adopted must have a clear basis and rationale. Using a TMS allows you to generate reports based on shipping data, which is undoubtedly very useful.

These reports can help you with data-driven efficiency analysis. This way, you might be able to implement new rules that will hopefully improve efficiency.

Read Also: What Is Fleet Management in Logistics?

Illustration of detecting trucks violating speed limits on a digital map system as part of the Transportation Management System feature.

Manage your fleet more efficiently with Cartrack's Fleet Management System.

If your business focuses more on fleet utilisation than deliveries, a Fleet Management System is the right solution for you. Cartrack offers an FMS solution that makes it easy to manage your fleet, with features like:

You can also add other features as needed such as Start Inhibit Relay, Cargo Door Sensor, PTO Sensor, and so on.

That concludes our discussion of Transportation Management Systems (TMS) and their differences from Delivery Management Systems and Fleet Management Systems. Make sure you use the right system for your business needs.

For those of you focused on vehicle management—such as in the car rental business—Cartrack’s Fleet Management solution may be the right fit for you. Please provide your details in the form below to receive a quote from Cartrack and a live demo!

Familiar with FTL and LTL methods in large-scale Freight Forwarding

When shipping large quantities of goods, will you rent one truck for your goods only or share it with other shippers?

If you choose a shipping method that dedicates one truck to your goods, your shipment is FTL. If you choose to share space and costs with other shippers, your shipping method is LTL.

So, what are FTL and LTL? Let’s explore their definitions, the differences between them, and the factors to consider for shipping efficiency. Furthermore, we will also discuss how fleet management technology can serve as a security solution for your shipments.

Understanding FTL and LTL

Large-scale cargo shipments are categorized into two methods: FTL (Full Truckload) and LTL (Less-than Truckload).

What is FTL?

FTL stands for Full Truckload, which refers to shipping large quantities of cargo that fill the entire truck's carrying capacity. FTL typically involves only one shipper with a single destination, for example, from a factory to a warehouse.

However, in modern logistics, full FTL shipping can also mean you pay the full shipping cost even if you don't fill the truck to capacity. Furthermore, as long as the shipper is the same, you can specify multiple drop-offs.

Advantages of FTL

  • More flexible schedule

  • Items arrive faster

  • Safer because it is not mixed with other items

  • Suitable for sensitive items and those requiring special treatment.

FTL disadvantages

  • The cost is more expensive because you rent a truck yourself.

  • Still pay in full even if you don't fill the truck to the brim.

What is LTL?

LTL stands for Less-than Truckload, which refers to a shipment that utilizes only a portion of a truck's capacity. This method allows you to share space and shipping costs with other shippers who are using the same service.

In an LTL (Less-Than-Truckload) shipment, the full capacity of a truck is shared among multiple shippers with various destinations. This method is commonly used by small-scale businesses, such as SMEs.

Advantages of LTL

  • The cost is cheaper because it is calculated based on the weight of the load.

  • Suitable for MSME businesses

  • More environmentally friendly because the truck load is maximised.

Disadvantages of LTL

  • It takes longer because there are many transits.

  • Delivery time is not flexible because it has to wait for other loads.

  • The risk of damaged goods is higher because they are loaded together with other goods.

  • Not suitable for cargo requiring special treatment

Empty wooden truck trailer interior with stacks of white cardboard boxes for large scale freight shipments using FTL or LTL methods.

Differences between FTL and LTL in Shipping Operations

After understanding the meaning, advantages and disadvantages of each FTL and LTL method, this time we will compare the differences between the two.

Factor

FTL (Full Truckload)

LTL (Less Than Truckload)

Truck Capacity Usage

One shipper rents one truck (full or not full)

One truck carries goods from several shippers

Number of Senders & Recipients

1 sender, 1 or more recipients (can be multiple drop-offs)

Many senders, many recipients

Delivery Speed

Faster, because it goes straight to the destination

It takes longer, because you have to transit several times.

Cost

More expensive, because it is charged for one truck

More economical, because costs are based on the volume of goods

Goods Security

Safer, because it is not mixed with other items

More risky, because the shipment is mixed with other goods

Suitable Types of Goods

Large volume, fragile items, and fast delivery

Small volume, not too sensitive items

When to Use FTL or LTL?

When planning a freight shipment, you need to understand the ideal situations for selecting FTL or LTL. Things to consider include:

1. Cargo weight

The amount of cargo to be shipped depends on the type of fleet used. For example, a tronton truck has a capacity of 18 tons. If your cargo weighs close to 18 tons, you can choose the FTL method.

Conversely, if your cargo weight exceeds the truck's capacity, you can choose the LTL method. You can also contact your logistics provider directly for recommendations based on your needs.

2. Urgency of delivery

The next thing you should consider is the urgency of the shipment. If you need fast delivery, you should use the FTL method, which will deliver the goods directly to their final destination.

However, if delivery times are more flexible, choosing LTL won't be a problem. LTL shipments will take longer because they'll transit through a warehouse or distribution point before being delivered to their destination.

3. Type of goods

The type of goods you're shipping will also be a crucial consideration when choosing a shipping method. If the items you're shipping don't require special attention, LTL won't be a problem.

However, if you're shipping sensitive, fragile, or high-value items, you'll want to use FTL. This reduces the risk of items coming into contact with other items, which could cause damage.

4. Budget

Another consideration that is no less important is budget considerations for shipping. If your budget is limited, choosing LTL is the best, especially if your cargo is not too large and does not require special attention.

If budget isn't your priority for fast and safe shipping, FTL is the perfect solution. Using FTL will improve time and operational efficiency.

Cargo Capacity for FTL & LTL Shipping

Apart from the four things above, the next thing you can consider is the load capacity of the logistics fleet you will choose.

Please note that each shipping company has its own standards and requirements for the load capacity of its fleet. However, as an estimate, you can refer to the following table.

Truck Type

Dimensions (P x L x T) (m)

Load Capacity (kg)

Engkel Box (CDE)

3 x 1.6 x 1.6

±2.000 kg (2 ton)

CDD Box

4.2 x 1.9 x 1.8

±4.000 kg (4 ton)

Fuso Light

5.5 x 2.1 x 2.0

±8.000 kg (8 ton)

Heavy Fuso

6.5 x 2.2 x 2.2

±12.000 kg (12 ton)

Tronton Box

9.5 x 2.3 x 2.3

±18.000 kg (18 ton)

Wingbox / Trailer 20ft

6 x 2.4 x 2.2

±20.000 kg (20 ton)

Wingbox / Trailer 40ft

12 x 2.4 x 2.4

±30.000 kg (30 ton)

If the weight of your shipment reaches 80% of your fleet capacity, you can choose the FTL method. If it's less than 80%, LTL is a more cost-effective option.

Besides measuring weight, truck loads can also be calculated using pallets. The number of pallets a truck can carry also varies depending on the truck type and the shipping service's policies.

Common pallet sizes used in Indonesia are 1100 mm x 1100 mm (Indonesian standard) and 1200 x 800 mm (European standard). Shipping companies typically also limit the height of each pallet to ensure cargo is secure during transit.

Palletized shipping is common in industries that ship uniform, uniformly shaped cargo. Therefore, it's often used for factory-to-warehouse shipments using the FTL method.

Example of FTL and LTL Usage Scenarios

To help you better understand the differences, here are some examples of scenarios where FTL and LTL methods are used.

One example of the use of the FTL method is shipping from a factory to a distributor's warehouse. For example, an electronics factory in Karawang might ship 1,000 refrigerators to a distributor's warehouse in Jakarta.

Another example is when a factory or warehouse ships products on a large scale. For example, a cement factory in Gresik might send a truckload of 18 tons of cement to a construction project in Tegal.

Meanwhile, examples of LTL methods include smaller-scale shipments. For example, a shipment of 500 prayer robes weighing approximately 500 kg from a local tailor in Bogor to a clothing store in Tanah Abang Market.

Another example is when a warehouse of an electronics distributor for brand A ships 100 laptops to an authorised reseller. The LTL method used is LTL because 100 laptops only take up about 20% of the truck's capacity.

A green forklift operator is loading large cardboard boxes into a container for large-scale shipping.

Optimise Shipping Security with Cartrack

For those of you in the logistics business, optimising shipping security is a priority. Whether shipping via FTL or LTL, you can utilise a fleet management system like Cartrack to:

  • GPS Tracker: Cartrack provides real-time GPS tracking that allows you to monitor your logistics fleet. Ensure every FTL and LTL shipment is always monitored and follows the designated route.

  • Cartrack Delivery: Cartrack's Delivery Management System will help you manage deliveries, delegate drivers, and optimise routes. This will greatly assist you in managing your fleet and deliveries.

  • LiveVision and SmartCabin: Cartrack’s visibility solutions offer dashcams as well as AI-powered fleet cameras. Beyond monitoring drivers, these cameras can be installed both inside and outside the vehicle to enhance safety.

  • Fuel Monitoring: Fuel sensors will help you monitor fuel usage across your fleet. This will alert you to any fuel theft, which can be detrimental to operations.

  • Cargo Door Sensor: To prevent shipments from being compromised by the inclusion of unauthorised items that could disrupt operations, you can also install a cargo door sensor. This allows you to know if the cargo door is opened before reaching the destination.

For those of you in the logistics and shipping business, Cartrack’s fleet management solutions will make managing your deliveries easier. From GPS trackers to cargo door sensors, Cartrack can help enhance the security of your business and your fleet.

Are you the owner or manager of a logistics and shipping business? Provide your details via the following link to receive a consultation and a special offer from Cartrack!